Y’all Check Out My Rebus

The ballplayers above share nothing but a love of the game, the ability to look good in a round-topped, large-billed cap, and the appearance of their names in at least one sentence of standard English. Not just any sentence, mind you; a Memorable Quote from a Classic Film. Proceed.

Should you be the first to crack my rebus, I will a) write all about it in my diary and b) reward you by letting you name the topic of my next post. (Click to embiggen)